OneBrowsing > Compare > Supply Chain Management > Acumatica vs Amber Road vs 3DEXPERIENCE: 20 Pros & Cons

Acumatica vs Amber Road vs 3DEXPERIENCE: 20 Pros & Cons

Updated on 24 Mar 2025

OneBrowsing

 4.3

 4.2

 4.5

(Reviews: 1.5K)

Est. users: 200K

Price Ranges: $50 - $100 - $300

Acumatica vs Amber Road vs 3DEXPERIENCE

Acumatica is a cloud-based enterprise resource planning (ERP) solution focused on providing business management applications for small to mid-sized companies, while Amber Road is a trade compliance and global trade management software for companies dealing with international shipping and customs. In contrast, 3DEXPERIENCE is a platform developed by Dassault Systèmes that provides 3D design, engineering, and product lifecycle management tools for industries such as aerospace, automotive, and industrial equipment.

Acumatica

  1. Cloud-based ERP platform
  2. Focused on business management
  3. Offers financial management tools
  4. Provides CRM capabilities
  5. Customizable and scalable for growth

Amber Road

  1. Specializes in global trade management
  2. Supports international logistics
  3. Emphasizes trade compliance solutions
  4. Offers supply chain visibility
  5. Focused on import/export regulations

3DEXPERIENCE

  1. Platform for 3D design and simulation
  2. Integrates PLM and CAD tools
  3. Supports collaborative product development
  4. Used for manufacturing processes
  5. Offers virtual twin experiences

Key Differences

  1. Industry Focus

    3DEXPERIENCE is tailored specifically towards manufacturing and product design sectors, leveraging CAD and PLM tools. Acumatica is more broadly focused on various business verticals such as manufacturing, distribution, and retail, while Amber Road is specialized in global trade management.

    Winner: 3DEXPERIENCE

  2. Cloud Deployment

    Acumatica is cloud-first, offering robust cloud-native capabilities and flexible deployment options. Amber Road provides cloud-based solutions primarily for trade management, and 3DEXPERIENCE also offers cloud capabilities but initially was more on-premises focused.

    Winner: Acumatica

  3. Supply Chain Management

    Amber Road excels with its focus on trade compliance and global sourcing solutions, whereas Acumatica provides more general ERP capabilities, and 3DEXPERIENCE focuses on CAD and PLM with limited direct supply chain features.

    Winner: Amber Road

  4. Integration Capabilities

    3DEXPERIENCE is designed to integrate seamlessly with other Dassault Systèmes products and PLM systems. Acumatica is known for its open architecture and flexibility, supporting various third-party integrations. Amber Road, being niche-focused, offers integrations specific to trade management.

    Winner: Acumatica

  5. Customization

    Acumatica offers extensive customization capabilities allowing for tailored business processes and specific industry needs. 3DEXPERIENCE provides customization primarily through its PLM solutions, while Amber Road offers customization focused on trade compliance.

    Winner: Acumatica

  6. User Interface and Experience

    3DEXPERIENCE provides a highly visual and intuitive interface geared towards designers and engineers. Acumatica offers a more traditional ERP interface, which is user-friendly but less visually oriented. Amber Road's interface is designed around trade compliance functions.

    Winner: 3DEXPERIENCE

Distinct Features

AcumaticaAmber Road3DEXPERIENCE
Comprehensive ERP platform with integrated accounting, inventory management, and project accounting.Focused on global trade management and compliance.Unified platform for product lifecycle management (PLM) and 3D design.
User-friendly dashboards and customizable KPIs.Comprehensive global trade content including tariffs, regulations, and denied party screening.Advanced 3D modeling and simulation capabilities.
Real-time financial analysis and automated accounting processes.Automated trade compliance processes and documentation.Collaboration tools for design, engineering, and product development.
Deployment flexibility: cloud, on-premise, or hybrid solutions.Trade visibility and logistics management tools for monitoring global shipments.Integration of CAD, CAM, and CAE tools in a single platform.
Native integration with other Acumatica applications like CRM and eCommerce.Supply chain collaboration for enhanced communication and coordination among partners.Industry-specific solutions for sectors like aerospace, automotive, and consumer goods.

Pricing Overview

3DEXPERIENCE

View Pricing Plans  

  1. Basic Plan ($50) - Ideal for freelancers and students
  2. Professional Plan ($100) - Recommended for engineering firms
  3. Enterprise Plan ($300) - Designed for multinational companies

Basic Plan

$50 / Monthly

Entry-level plan for individuals

  • 3D Design

  • Collaboration Tools

Professional Plan

$100 / Monthly

Suitable for small to medium enterprises

  • Advanced Simulation

  • Project Management

Enterprise Plan

$300 / Monthly

Comprehensive plan for large corporations

  • Big Data Integration

  • Custom Workflows

Indepth Overview

AcumaticaAmber Road3DEXPERIENCE
ERP and Supply Chain Management
Cloud Accessibility ★4.8 - Fully cloud-based solution enables easy access anywhere.
Customization ★4.5 - Highly customizable to fit unique business needs.
Integration ★4.7 - Compatible with various third-party applications for seamless workflows. ★4.4 - Integrates well with various ERP systems for broader functionality.
Reporting and Analytics ★4.6 - Advanced reporting features provide deep insights into operations.
User Experience ★4.5 - Intuitive interface designed for efficiency and accessibility.
Global Trade Management ★4.6 - Comprehensive tools tailored for managing global trade efficiently.
Compliance Management ★4.7 - Provides robust compliance tools to minimize trade risks.
Logistics Module ★4.5 - Effective logistics management capabilities for supply chain optimization.
Data Accuracy ★4.6 - High data accuracy ensuring compliance and trade efficiency.
3D Modeling ★4.9 - Advanced 3D modeling capabilities for product design.
Collaboration Tools ★4.7 - Excellent collaborative features supporting teamwork in real-time.
Simulation ★4.8 - Powerful simulation tools for product testing before production.
Industry Solutions ★4.6 - Tailored solutions for various industries supported.
Cloud Capabilities ★4.5 - Strong cloud functionalities for data accessibility and collaboration.
Supply Chain and Manufacturing
Inventory Management ★4.6 - Efficient tracking of inventory in real-time.
Demand Planning ★4.5 - Tools for forecasting demand accurately.
Order Management ★4.7 - Streamlined order processing features.
Cost Management ★4.5 - Provides tools for effective cost control.
Production Management ★4.4 - Robust production planning functionalities.
Trade Compliance ★4.8 - Ensures readiness for global trade regulations.
Supply Chain Visibility ★4.6 - Comprehensive visibility across the supply chain.
Freight Management ★4.5 - Tools for managing freight costs and logistics.
Risk Management ★4.7 - Dedicated features for identifying and mitigating risks.
Workflow Management ★4.4 - Effective tools to automate and manage workflows.
Project Management ★4.8 - Advanced project management tools integrated with design processes.
Manufacturing Execution ★4.6 - Real-time monitoring of manufacturing processes.
Product Lifecycle Management ★4.7 - Comprehensive PLM capabilities enhance product development.
Data Visualization ★4.5 - 3D visualizations improve understanding of complex data.
Sustainability Features ★4.5 - Tools to support sustainable manufacturing practices.

Comparision Reviews

Jordan Flynn

Seattle, WA

Acumatica excels in customization and ease of use, making it a good choice for businesses seeking a flexible ERP solution. On the other hand, Amber Road shines with its robust compliance and trade management features, crucial for companies involved in international trade. While Acumatica offers a broader suite of general ERP functions, Amber Road's specialized capabilities can significantly benefit global logistics operations.

Acumatica 4.3

Amber Road 4.1

Morgan Lee

Toronto, ON

Amber Road provides unmatched trade compliance tools, which are essential for reducing risks in global operations. However, Acumatica brings more comprehensive finance and project management functionalities, aiding businesses in domestic markets. Acumatica also offers a superior user interface, enhancing the overall user experience, while Amber Road's strength lies in niche functionalities.

Acumatica 4.5

Amber Road 4.2

Taylor Johnson

Austin, TX

In terms of scalability, Acumatica is fantastic for growing businesses due to its adaptable cloud-based infrastructure. Amber Road, however, is critically effective for organizations that prioritize international supply chain management and trade compliance. For small to mid-sized businesses that require basic ERP needs, Acumatica might be more cost-effective.

Acumatica 4

Amber Road 3.8

Reese Kim

London, UK

Amber Road stands out with its advanced analytics and supply chain visibility, crucial for enterprises involved in complex international trade. Acumatica, however, is more user-friendly and offers better integration with third-party applications, making it favorable for businesses that require a versatile ERP system.

Acumatica 4.4

Amber Road 4

Alex Carter

Sydney, AU

Acumatica offers excellent customer support and flexible pricing, which can provide great value for money for small enterprises. Amber Road's extensive trade facilitation features are ideal for large companies looking for deep specialization in import-export operations. Although both systems have their own strengths, the choice depends largely on business needs.

Acumatica 4.1

Amber Road 4.3

Comments

Alice B.
Hey guys, which do you think is better for managing supply chain logistics—Acumatica, Amber Road, or 3DEXPERIENCE? 🤔
Bob_42
I've been using Acumatica at work, and it's pretty good. It has an easy-to-use interface, but sometimes it's a bit slow. 🙄
Dave92
Amber Road is great for compliance and risk management. That's kinda its strong suit. But I haven't tried the others much. 📦
Bob_42
@Dave92, I heard Amber Road's automation helps reduce manual work. Is that true??
Dave92
Yeah, it does help cut down on manual processes! Which is a lifesaver if you're dealing with tons of shipments. 😅
Chloe Z.
3DEXPERIENCE is like the ultimate platform for product lifecycle management, but it's overkill if you're just looking for logistics solutions.
Ethan T.
I agree with Chloe. 👀 3DEXPERIENCE is powerful and integrates well across design and engineering, but it's expensive.
Alice B.
So if you're budget-conscious and don't mind a bit of lag, Acumatica could work. Amber Road if compliance is key, and 3DEXPERIENCE for the full package?
Chloe Z.
Yep, and if you hit the lotto, go for 3DEXPERIENCE. 😂

External Links For More Information

Related Posts

Leave a Comment