Tiller Money vs Quicken: Which Budgeting Tool Is Best?

Updated on 10 Nov 2024

OneBrowsing

 4.5

(Reviews: 250)

Est. users: 50K

Price Ranges: $6 - $9

 4.1

(Reviews: 15K)

Est. users: 2M

Price Ranges: $34.99 - $49.99 - $74.99

Tiller Money vs Quicken

Tiller Money and Quicken are both personal finance tools, but they differ in their approaches and features. Tiller Money focuses on automating and organizing financial data using spreadsheets, offering flexibility through Google Sheets or Microsoft Excel for users who prefer customizable reports. Quicken, on the other hand, is a more traditional software providing comprehensive financial management, including budgeting, bill tracking, and investment monitoring, through a dedicated application interface with robust pre-built features.

Tiller Money

  1. Google Sheets integration
  2. Automatic financial data updates
  3. Subscription-based pricing
  4. Customizable spreadsheets
  5. Focus on budgeting
  6. No mobile app available

Quicken

  1. Desktop and mobile apps
  2. Robust investment tracking
  3. One-time purchase or subscription
  4. Comprehensive budgeting tools
  5. Bill management feature
  6. Historical data import

Key Differences

  1. User Interface

    Tiller Money offers a spreadsheet-based interface that integrates with Google Sheets, providing customizable templates for tracking finances. Quicken has a more traditional standalone application interface with built-in features and visualizations.

    Winner: Its a tie

  2. Customization

    Tiller Money is highly customizable through its Google Sheets integration, allowing users to modify templates and create bespoke financial tracking systems. Quicken provides some flexibility but generally has more predefined categories and reports.

    Winner: Tiller Money

  3. Automation

    Quicken offers robust automation features including automatic categorization of transactions and bill tracking. Tiller Money offers automation for importing transactions into Google Sheets but requires manual setup for advanced features.

    Winner: Quicken

  4. Cost

    Tiller Money operates on a subscription model that can be more affordable for users who only need core features. Quicken offers both subscription-based and one-time purchase options but can be more expensive overall for comprehensive features.

    Winner: Tiller Money

  5. Platform Availability

    Quicken is available as a desktop application for Windows and Mac, with associated mobile apps. Tiller Money works within the Google Sheets ecosystem, making it accessible from any device with internet access.

    Winner: Its a tie

  6. Ease of Use

    Quicken has a more guided setup and built-in functionalities that require less initial setup, making it more user-friendly for those looking for a ready-to-use solution. Tiller Money demands more setup time for Google Sheets customization, which may be challenging for some users.

    Winner: Quicken

  7. Data Control and Privacy

    Tiller Money's reliance on Google Sheets allows users more control over their data since it is stored within their Google account. Quicken stores financial data in its own ecosystem, which might raise privacy considerations for some users.

    Winner: Tiller Money

Distinct Features

Tiller MoneyQuicken
Integrates with Google Sheets and Microsoft Excel for customizable budgeting and trackingStandalone desktop application with a comprehensive personal finance management interface
Automated daily import of bank transactions directly into spreadsheetsInvestment tracking with the ability to handle complex portfolios and detailed performance reports
Highly customizable templates allowing for personalized financial trackingBill management and payment directly through the application
Focus on spreadsheet management without a standalone applicationRobust set of budgeting tools integrated directly into the software
Subscription-based service with a focus on privacy (no ads, no selling of data)In-depth reporting and analysis features built into the platform
Mobile app for on-the-go access to financial data

Pricing Overview

Tiller Money

View Pricing Plans  

  1. Starter Plan ($6) - Individuals looking to track and manage their personal finances efficiently
  2. Premium Plan ($9) - Users seeking advanced financial tracking and planning features

Starter Plan

$6 / monthly

Entry-level plan for personal finance tracking

  • Categorize transactions

  • Basic budgeting tools

  • Manual transaction sync

Premium Plan

$9 / monthly

Comprehensive plan for detailed financial management

  • Automated transaction sync

  • Advanced budgeting tools

  • Debt payoff planning

  • Investment tracking

Quicken

View Pricing Plans  

  1. Starter ($34.99) - Ideal for individuals or households with basic financial needs
  2. Deluxe ($49.99) - Suitable for users looking for more comprehensive financial management
  3. Premier ($74.99) - Designed for users with complex investment portfolios and tax considerations

Starter

$34.99 / Annually

Basic plan for personal finance management

  • Budgeting

  • Bill Management

  • Custom Invoices

  • Expense Tracking

Deluxe

$49.99 / Annually

Advanced plan with investment tracking and debt reduction tools

  • Investment Tracking

  • Debt Reduction Plan

  • Priority Customer Support

Premier

$74.99 / Annually

Comprehensive plan with advanced investment and tax features

  • Advanced Investment Tools

  • Tax Deduction Tracking

  • Rental Property Management

Indepth Overview

Tiller MoneyQuicken
Budgeting Software
Spreadsheet Integration ★4.5 - Seamless Google Sheets integration for customizable budgeting. ★3.0 - Limited integration options, primarily a standalone application.
Automated Transactions ★4.0 - Automatic syncing of bank transactions to spreadsheets. ★4.5 - Automatic import of transactions from many banks.
Customizable Templates ★4.0 - Variety of templates for personalized financial tracking. ★4.3 - Various financial reports, but less spreadsheet flexibility.
Real-time Updates ★4.2 - Real-time data updates from linked accounts. ★3.8 - Updates occur at specific intervals rather than in real-time.
Data Ownership ★5.0 - Users own their data completely unlike cloud-stored options. ★4.0 - Data is stored locally, but also on the cloud.
Expense Tracking
Transaction Categorization ★4.7 - Highly customizable categorization through sheets. ★4.3 - Automatic categorization based on transaction history.
Mobile App Availability ★3.5 - No dedicated app; functionality through Google Sheets. ★4.0 - Standalone app available for both iOS and Android.
Expense Reports ★4.0 - Generate detailed reports easily via spreadsheets. ★4.2 - Comprehensive reporting features built into the software.
Alerts and Notifications ★2.5 - Lacks built-in alert system for budget limits. ★4.5 - Custom alerts for bill due dates and budgets.
Collaboration Features ★4.0 - Share spreadsheets with others for collaborative budgeting. ★3.0 - Limited collaboration features; primarily personal use.
Investment Tracking
Investment Tracking Capability ★3.5 - Basic investment tracking through manual setup. ★4.5 - Strong investment tracking with automatic updates.
Portfolio Performance Reports ★3.0 - Requires manual creation of performance reports. ★4.0 - Detailed performance reports generated automatically.
Asset Allocation Tools ★2.5 - Limited tools for managing asset allocation. ★4.2 - Helpful tools for managing and analyzing asset allocation.
Real-time Market Data ★2.0 - No direct access to live market feeds. ★4.0 - Provides access to live market data for equities.
Linking Investment Accounts ★3.0 - Manual feeding of investment data necessary. ★4.5 - Automatically links to investment accounts for tracking.
Reports & Analytics
Types of Reports ★4.0 - Users can create custom reports via Google Sheets. ★4.8 - Comprehensive reports for budgeting, net worth, and taxes.
Data Analysis Tools ★3.5 - Limited analysis tools compared to traditional software. ★4.5 - Advanced analysis tools built into the software.
Historical Data Access ★4.0 - Historical data available via spreadsheets. ★4.5 - Maintains a robust history of all transactions.
Visualizations ★4.5 - Utilize Google Sheet functions for visualizations. ★4.0 - Good visual aids and charts for financial analysis.
Custom Reports ★5.0 - Allows complete flexibility in report creation. ★4.2 - Allows some degree of customization in reporting.
Support & Resources
Customer Support ★4.0 - Email support with a robust FAQ section. ★3.5 - Limited support options with longer wait times.
Community Forum ★4.2 - Active user community for tips and advice. ★4.0 - Strong community forum with active participation.
Tutorials and Guides ★4.5 - Extensive resources on getting started and advanced use. ★4.2 - Excellent resources for beginner and advanced users.
Webinars and Workshops ★4.0 - Occasional webinars available for users. ★3.5 - Rarely scheduled webinars for users.
Documentation ★4.3 - Well-maintained documentation available online. ★4.0 - Comprehensive documentation available online.

Comparision Reviews

Alex Thompson

Boston, MA

When comparing Tiller Money and Quicken, Tiller Money stands out for its seamless integration with Google Sheets, allowing flexibility and customization for those who prefer a spreadsheet approach. However, Quicken offers more comprehensive financial reporting and investment tracking tools that are ideal for users needing a more robust financial overview. Tiller Money doesn't provide extensive built-in budgeting tools like Quicken, but it compensates with its clean, customizable approach ideal for tech-savvy users. Quicken’s customer support is also more established.

Tiller Money 4.2

Quicken 4.5

Jessica Lee

San Francisco, CA

For those who prioritize straightforward budgeting features, Tiller Money is a great choice due to its simplicity and ease of use. It effortlessly links with bank accounts and updates automatically in Google Sheets. Quicken, on the other hand, offers superior visualization tools and detailed insights into spending patterns. It excels in tracking investment portfolios and providing in-depth reports, making it more suitable for users with complex financial needs.

Tiller Money 3.9

Quicken 4.6

Roger Davis

Austin, TX

In terms of customization and flexibility, Tiller Money has the upper hand. The ability to create personalized templates in Google Sheets is a big plus. However, Quicken's desktop application provides a more comprehensive package with features like bill management, debt tracking, and various financial insights. This makes Quicken a more holistic solution for users needing thorough financial management.

Tiller Money 4.0

Quicken 4.3

Lisa Green

Seattle, WA

Tiller Money shines with its streamlined approach and automatic data syncing to Google Sheets, which is perfect for anyone who wants real-time updates in a familiar spreadsheet format. Quicken is better equipped for users who want detailed investment management and advanced budgeting tools, although its learning curve is steeper. Both services have their benefits, but Quicken wins in terms of feature breadth.

Tiller Money 4.1

Quicken 4.4

Kevin Harper

Miami, FL

Those who value detailed, data-driven insights might lean towards Quicken, which offers powerful reporting and analysis capabilities. On the other hand, Tiller Money provides an efficient, user-driven experience since it allows for extensive customization. It’s an excellent choice for spreadsheet enthusiasts who prefer a hands-on approach to budgeting. If simplicity is the goal, Tiller is preferable; for a wide array of financial tools, Quicken is unbeatable.

Tiller Money 4.3

Quicken 4.7

Comments

Alex Johnson
Hey everyone, what do you guys think about Tiller Money vs Quicken? I'm thinking of switching from Quicken.
Samantha_M
1 - Oh, I've used both! Tiller is pretty cool because it integrates with Google Sheets for customizable reports.
Jordan Marks
2 - I love Tiller's automation with spreadsheet updates, but it's a bit pricey compared to Quicken.
Alex Johnson
4 - So true, Jordan! I hate how Tiller costs more tho. Does anyone know any discounts?
Jordan Marks
6 - Not sure about discounts. Maybe try emailing their support; they might have promotions.
Chris87
1 - But Quicken has been around forever and their budgeting tools are rock solid.
MeganT
3 - I agree, Chris87, but Quicken's UI feels kinda old-school. Don't you think?
Samantha_M
5 - Haha, yes MeganT. It's like stepping into a time capsule! But it's reliable.
Chris87
5.1 - Really? I kinda like the nostalgia, but I get it. Tiller's flexibility is its big plus.
MeganT
1 - Plus, with Quicken's security, I feel it's more robust given all my info is organized securely in one place.
Alex Johnson
10 - That's a good point, Megan. Maybe I'm just resisting change, haha.

External Links For More Information

Related Posts

Leave a Comment