23andMe vs AncestryDNA vs MyHeritage: DNA Test Review

OneBrowsing

4.5

(Reviews: 15K)

Est. users: 12M

Price Ranges: $79 - $179

4.5

(Reviews: 70K)

Est. users: 20M

Price Ranges: $99 - $149

4.5

(Reviews: 8.4K)

Est. users: 90M

Price Ranges: $129 - $209 - $299 - $399

23andMe vs AncestryDNA vs MyHeritage

23andMe, AncestryDNA, and MyHeritage are popular genetic testing services that differ primarily in their focus and database sizes. 23andMe offers health-related insights alongside ancestry information and has a strong emphasis on genetic health reports. AncestryDNA is renowned for its extensive family tree and historical records integration, allowing deeper genealogical research, while MyHeritage is known for its multilingual global database and useful tools for family tree building and genealogy enthusiasts.

23andMe

  1. Offers health and trait reports
  2. FDA-authorized genetic health tests
  3. Provides maternal and paternal haplogroups
  4. Focuses on scientific research participation
  5. Large database for health-related insights
  6. Includes wellness and carrier status reports

AncestryDNA

  1. Largest genealogical database
  2. Strong focus on family tree building
  3. Ancestry subscription offers additional tools
  4. Provides historical records access
  5. Has a user-friendly tree-building interface
  6. Regularly updated ethnicity estimates

MyHeritage

  1. Offers chromosome browser tool
  2. Integration with Geni for family trees
  3. Provides health screening as an add-on
  4. Specializes in European ancestry
  5. Affordable subscription for premium features
  6. Vibrant international user community

Key Differences

  1. Database Size for Ancestry

    AncestryDNA has a larger database of users, which can result in more accurate ancestry estimates and the potential to connect with more relatives.

    Winner: AncestryDNA

  2. Health Reports

    23andMe provides comprehensive health reports, assessing genetic predispositions to certain health conditions alongside ancestry results.

    Winner: 23andMe

  3. International Population Mapping

    MyHeritage often shows strengths in its coverage of international DNA samples, which may be beneficial for users with diverse backgrounds.

    Winner: MyHeritage

  4. Ease of Use

    All services offer user-friendly platforms, but 23andMe is often praised for its straightforward and comprehensive reports.

    Winner: 23andMe

  5. Family Tree Integration

    AncestryDNA provides robust integration with family tree software, making it easy to connect DNA results with genealogical data.

    Winner: AncestryDNA

  6. Price Range and Value

    MyHeritage often presents itself as a more affordable option, offering competitive pricing for both ancestry and health insights.

    Winner: MyHeritage

  7. Ethnic Regions and Detail

    AncestryDNA is known for its detailed ethnic regions and updates, which are often considered more refined compared to the competition.

    Winner: AncestryDNA

Distinct Features

23andMeAncestryDNAMyHeritage
Genetic Health Risk ReportsExtensive historical records and genealogical resourcesEthnicity Estimate with unique Genetic Groups
Carrier Status ReportsFamily tree building toolsAutoClusters for visualizing DNA matches
Wellness ReportsHints for family lineage based on historical dataFamily tree consistency checker
Pharmacogenetics ReportsAccess to Ancestry's vast digital archive of documentsSpecialized tools for Jewish ancestry research
Exclusive FDA-approved health reportsThruLines feature for exploring family connectionsCultural and historical overviews for ethnicity matches

Pricing Overview

23andMe

  1. Basic Plan ($79) - For beginners or those looking for introductory genetic information.
  2. Health + Ancestry Plan ($179) - For individuals interested in detailed health and ancestry insights.

Basic Plan

$79 / One-time

Ideal for individuals interested in basic ancestry and health insights.

  • Ancestry reports

  • Raw DNA data

  • Wellness reports

Health + Ancestry Plan

$179 / One-time

Suitable for those looking for comprehensive health and ancestry information.

  • Maps of ancestry composition

  • Carrier status reports

  • Access to genetic counseling resources

AncestryDNA

  1. Basic Plan ($99) - Ideal for individuals interested in basic ancestry information
  2. Premium Plan ($149) - Suitable for users seeking detailed ancestry insights

Basic Plan

$99 / One-time

Entry-level plan for exploring your ancestry

  • Ethnicity Estimate

  • DNA Matches

  • Interactive Tools

Premium Plan

$149 / One-time

Enhanced plan with more detailed information

  • Everything in Basic Plan

  • Additional Regions

  • Priority Support

MyHeritage

  1. Premium ($129 /year) - For users looking for advanced features and priority support
  2. PremiumPlus ($209 /year) - For users needing access to unlimited historical records data
  3. Complete ($299 /year) - For users looking for the complete package with unlimited features
  4. Omni ($399 /year) - For users seeking the ultimate package with all features unrestricted

Premium

$129 /year / 1st year: $89

Enhanced family tree

  • Smart Matchesu2122

  • Advanced DNA features

  • Instant Discoveriesu2122

  • Tree Consistency Checker

  • 20.9 Billion Historical Records

  • Record Matches

  • Save records to your tree

  • Photo Enhancement Features

  • Historical Newspapers on OldNews.com

  • Geni.com Pro and over 2,000 Webinars

  • Unlimited Photo Scanning

  • Enhanced family tree

PremiumPlus

$209 /year / 1st year: $149

Unlimited All historical records Data

  • Unlimited All historical records Data

Complete

$299 /year / 1st year: $199

The ultimate package

  • Unlimited The ultimate package

Omni

$399 /year / 1st year: $239

The ultimate package

  • Unlimited Learn more

Indepth Overview

23andMeAncestryDNAMyHeritage
DNA Testing and Ancestry Services
Health Reports ★4.5 - Provides health-related genetic information.
Ancestry Composition ★4.8 - Detailed breakdown of genetic ancestry.
Traits Reports ★4.3 - Insights on personal traits from DNA.
User-Friendly Interface ★4.5 - Intuitive design for results review. ★4.4 - Simple design for navigating results.★4.6 - Clean interface for easy navigation.
Ethnicity Estimate Updates ★4.6 - Regularly updates estimates based on new data.
Raw Data Download ★4.5 - Allows users to download their raw DNA data. ★4.5 - Allows users to download their raw DNA data.★4.5 - Option to download raw DNA data.
Genetic Relatives Feature ★4.4 - Connects users with genetic relatives.
Privacy Controls ★4.7 - Strong emphasis on user privacy options. ★4.6 - Provides robust privacy settings.★4.5 - Strong privacy features for user data.
Research Participation ★4.2 - Option to participate in genetic research.
Paternity Testing
Family Tree Integration ★4.7 - Easily integrates with Ancestry.com family trees.
Ethnicity Estimate ★4.9 - In-depth ethnicity breakdown by region.★4.6 - Detailed ancestry breakdown by regions.
Genetic Lock ★4.6 - Offers a feature to manage sharing.
Record & Historical Database ★4.8 - Access to extensive historical records.
DNA Matches ★4.7 - Connects with potential DNA matches.★4.7 - Connects users to genetic matches.
Ethnicity Updates ★4.8 - Regular updates to ethnicity estimates.
Global Reach ★4.5 - Extensive database for global ancestry.
Family Tree Builder ★4.7 - User-friendly family tree creation tool.
Record Matching ★4.8 - Matches historical records to family trees.
Photo Enhancements ★4.4 - Unique feature for enhancing old photos.

Comparision Reviews

Alex M.

San Francisco, CA

Both 23andMe and AncestryDNA offer comprehensive DNA testing services, but they cater to slightly different needs. 23andMe excels in providing detailed health insights, which are useful for those interested in genetic health reports. AncestryDNA, on the other hand, provides superior genealogical data, making it ideal for those interested in tracing their family history. The user interface for both services is intuitive, but AncestryDNA’s focus on historical records makes it more suitable for genealogy enthusiasts.

23andMe 4.5

AncestryDNA 4.2

Jordan L.

Austin, TX

While both services provide excellent genetic analysis, I found 23andMe's health reports to be more informative and beneficial. However, AncestryDNA's extensive database allows for deeper family tree exploration. In terms of result accuracy, both are quite reliable, but the additional health insights of 23andMe give it a slight edge for those concerned about wellness.

23andMe 4.7

AncestryDNA 4.3

Sam T.

New York, NY

In comparing 23andMe and AncestryDNA, I found 23andMe’s service to be slightly more expensive, but it’s justifiable if you're interested in both ancestry and health-related results. AncestryDNA offers a large network for building family trees and has vast public records, which is beneficial if your primary goal is exploring your ancestry deeper.

23andMe 4.4

AncestryDNA 4.6

Casey P.

Seattle, WA

23andMe and AncestryDNA both provide a solid starting point for genetic testing. 23andMe stands out in providing scientifically-backed health reports, whereas AncestryDNA shines brighter when it comes to historical ancestry and connecting with distant relatives. The choice largely depends on whether you want health information or to dive into family history.

23andMe 4.3

AncestryDNA 4.5

Taylor R.

Chicago, IL

Having used both 23andMe and AncestryDNA, I appreciate the specialized data each offers. 23andMe provides extensive health and trait reports which are lacking in AncestryDNA. However, AncestryDNA's strength lies in its ability to connect users with potential relatives and robust genealogical research tools. The user-friendliness and support of both services are commendable, but your choice will depend on your focus—health vs. heritage.

23andMe 4.6

AncestryDNA 4.4

Comments

Alice Chen
Hey guys, I've been thinking about diving into some genealogy research. Anyone tried 23andMe, AncestryDNA, or MyHeritage?
Bob254
Yo Alice! I gave AncestryDNA a shot last year. It was pretty cool, but the subscription for the full access kinda burns a hole in your wallet.
Charlie Nguyen
I've also used 23andMe! The health insights are a neat add-on that you don't get with AncestryDNA.
Lisa_M64
Yeah but Charlie, isn't the health stuff kind of scary? Like, what if they find out you're gonna mutate into a superhero or something?
Eve Samson
Haha Lisa! As cool as becoming a superhero sounds, there are actual privacy concerns. I read that 23andMe shares data with researchers.
Alice Chen
Eve, that's true. All these companies probably have terms we don't even read. I've heard MyHeritage is better with user data privacy.
Bob254
But does anyone else find MyHeritage's 'deep nostalgia' feature kinda creepy? Watch your ancestors blink and move - feels like Black Mirror.
Charlie Nguyen
Haha, Bob! I agree. It's a tad eerie. But on the bright side, MyHeritage sometimes offers more diverse ethnic origins compared to the other two.
Eve Samson
So what's the consensus? If you want health info go 23andMe, budget and ancestry go AncestryDNA, and privacy plus fun features go MyHeritage?
Lisa_M64
Precisely, Eve! I think it depends on what you prioritize. I don't think any of them are perfect though.

External Links For More Information

Related Posts

Leave a Comment